Councillors vote against further action on Clive of India statue

This article is more than 5 months old. Please read this page keeping its age in mind.

Shropshire Councillors have decided that the controversial Clive of India statue will remain in Shrewsbury’s Square.

The Statue of Clive of India in Shrewsbury's Square. Photo: Elliott Brown / CC BY-SA
The Statue of Clive of India in Shrewsbury’s Square. Photo: Elliott Brown / CC BY-SA

Today’s full council meeting included two public questions, a debate over a petition and a motion that involved a referendum all in relation to the controversial Robert Clive statue.

After the debate had taken place, Councillor Steve Charmley, Shropshire Council Deputy Leader, proposed no further action. Councillors approved this, 28 in favour, 17 against and with one abstention. There was some confusion over the new online voting system and one Councillor indicated that she wanted, but wasn’t allowed, to change her vote.

Several hours later, Councillors similarly voted down Councillor Nat Green’s motion, which involved a referendum, by 34 votes to 10 votes, with two abstentions.

The petition

There have been two recent change.org petitions in relation to Clive. One, titled “Replace Clive of India statute from Shrewsbury town centre”, at the time of writing, has over 9,000 signatures, while another, “Keep the Robert Clive statue in Shrewsbury”, now has over 9,300 signatures.

In the meeting, two public questions about the controversial statute in Shrewsbury Square were first asked.

Then, as, according to Shropshire Council, the former petition had 1,000 signatures by the deadline of 10am on Tuesday 14th July 2020, it was debated in the meeting. Its petitioner, Mr Jake Thompson, did not provide a statement.

Several councillors took part in the allotted 15 minute debate on the topic. Councillor Pauline Dee said that she strongly welcomed Black Lives Matter, but would vote against a referendum because she was concerned about an upcoming economic downturn because of COVID-19. She also voiced her concern over modern slavery. However, Councillor Julian Dean stated that “an injury to one is an injury to all” and that “there is no snowball”.

Councillor Peter Nutting, Shropshire Council Leader, said that he had received mass support for his stance on not taking the statue down. He said that he favoured an educational plaque either by the statue or in the museum, though noted that if it was by the statue, it could become a target. He also referred to a statue of Clive in Kolkata, West Bengal.

Perhaps controversially though, Councillor Nutting referred to Clive’s “so-called terrible deeds”. Several hours later, when asked about his use of “so-called” by Councillor Kevin Pardy, Councillor Nutting said that “there are various versions of those events” and that there needs to be “more investigation to say which are true and which aren’t true”.

Back in the debate, Councillor Charmley said that there was “no place for racism or prejudice of any type in our society”, but he explained that the statue was a grade two listed building and that it would be no simple task to take it down. A search on historicengland.org.uk confirms this. He also said that he favoured a plaque, probably in a museum because of the statue’s listing, but moved that no further action be taken. Councillors approved this.

The motion

Several hours later, a motion by Councillor Green was tabled.

Councillor Green’s, supported by the Liberal Democrat Group, motion was that:

– A history board giving a “balanced narrative” of Clive and his history should be erected and placed adjacent to the statue.

– After an information campaign in the media and perhaps public meetings, a referendum of the people of Shropshire on whether the statue should stay or go should take place.

In his motion, Councillor Green explained that “By taking this course of action, Shropshire Council will have shown itself mindful both of contemporary sensibilities, but not have been seen to have discarded the past on a whim.”

Councillor Andy Boddington substituted for Councillor Green in the meeting. He argued that he had no experience in relation to Councillor Charmley’s earlier concerns about the fact the statue was grade two listed. He suggested that there should be a hologram sculpture every month and that this could drive people to Shrewsbury.

He also said that “we’re not representative of the total population of Shropshire” and that the vote could be “like a petition, but run by us”.

An amendment was shot down and, ultimately, Councillor Green’s motion was not approved either.

Who was Robert Clive?

Robert Clive, known as Clive of India, was born in Market Drayton and lived between 1725 and 1774. He spent much of his time in India. He lived during the era of the colonial East India Company, which would go on to seize control over large parts of the Indian subcontinent. He was also the MP for Mitchell, Cornwall and then Shrewsbury. He also spent some time as Mayor of Shrewsbury and Lord Lieutenant of Shropshire.

The petition that advocates replacing the statue states that “He was described by Robert Dalrymple as an “unstable sociopath” and he committed mass atrocities and passed catastrophic policies in Bengal that reduced Bengal’s population by a third. He essentially looted the country of Bengal, with the majority of the blood money going straight into his pockets.” It goes on to state that having such a statue is “both offensive and embarrassing” and concludes “Let’s commemorate someone more worthy celebration.”

The petition that advocates keeping the statue reads that “Shrewsbury and Shropshire has been influenced by the actions of Robert Clive whether we condone all of his actions or not.” It begins “Removing statues does not change history nor help us learn from it. Shrewsbury and Shropshire has been influenced by the actions of Robert Clive whether we condone all of his actions or not.”

The public questions and Mr Thompson’s petition were item 5 and Councillor Green’s motion was motion 4 of item 16 on today’s agenda.

Supporting Shropshire Live...
Rowan Hall
Rowan contributes articles to Shropshire Live. A Law undergraduate who lives in the county. He is currently studying Global Law at Queen Mary University of London and has a particular interest in writing about local government.
Advertise with us for £50 per week

Advertisement Feature

Simply Ribbons is not what you would expect in more ways than one!

Catering for individuals, small businesses and multinationals Simply Ribbons offer high-quality ribbons from UK and European manufacturers.
Telford College - Employer incentives 1

Telford College offers cash incentives to local employers

Telford College is offering Government-funded cash incentives to Shropshire employers, to give young people a helping hand with their careers.
- Advertising -
Advertise with Shropshire Live for £50 per week
Arrest Handcuff Generic

Drug warrant leads to three arrests in Shrewsbury

Three people have been arrested for drug offences in Shrewsbury following a warrant.
Pictured celebrating the new High Street fund are, from left, Steph Burton of Dawley Launderette, Claudia Churchill of Hilbrae Charity Shop with Boo the dog and Monika Janczylo of Golden Rolls

Fund to boost Dawley High Street

Great Dawley Town Council has launched a ‘Community High Street Fund’ with £35,000 available to help bring new life to the area.
Fossil Free Shropshire demonstrated outside Shirehall dressed as scientists in order to highlight a controversial new report from the Shropshire County Pension Fund.

Campaigners reject Shropshire County Pension Fund’s new climate risk report

Campaigners from Fossil Free Shropshire, a grassroots group calling on the Shropshire County Pension Fund to stop investing in fossil fuels, protested outside Shirehall over the release of a new Climate Risk report at today's pension fund meeting.

Match Report: Shrewsbury Town 2 – 2 Accrington Stanley

Shrewsbury Town once again concede late on as Steve Cotterill’s first league game in charge ends with a share of the spoils.
Racing at Chelmarsh Sailing Club. Photo: Terry Gumbley

Chelmarsh Sailing Club shortlisted for national award

Chelmarsh Sailing Club has been shortlisted for a prestigious national award following a hugely successful year on the water despite the challenges of the Coronavirus pandemic.

Match Preview: Shrewsbury Town v Accrington Stanley

In a huge boost for Shrewsbury Town supporters, 2,000 of them will witness Steve Cotterill’s first league game in charge this evening.
- Advertising -
Shropshire Chamber of Commerce Chief executive Richard Sheehan

Shropshire Chamber says Government needs to do more to help businesses

Shropshire Chamber of Commerce is calling on the Government to ensure it is meeting five key tests to help power an economic recovery.
Brian Evans, managing partner of Lanyon Bowdler

Shropshire law firm maintains excellent rankings in national guide

A Shropshire law firm has maintained its excellent rankings in a national guide, with 14 lawyers highlighted as recommended practitioners.

New radio station aimed at the Shropshire business community launches online

A brand new online radio station aimed at the Shropshire business community has launched online.
Cards for Good Causes supports more than 250 national and local charities

Cards for Good Causes pop-up reopens in Ludlow

Cards for Good Causes in Ludlow has reopened in a new location for 2020 with social distancing and covid-19 precautions in place.
The lights and music will be on daily from 4:30pm through to 10pm

Charity Christmas lights shine bright in Higher Heath

For the third year running, a house in Twemlows Avenue, Higher Heath, Whitchurch will be decked with lights in aid of the Midlands Air Ambulance Charity (MAAC).
Denise Kerr

Oswestry nursery manager launches debut children’s book

A manager from a local Oswestry Nursery, Jeanette Pearson-Tanner, has launched her debut children’s book – ‘The Pre School Detectives’.
- Advertising -
The live highlights included the battle between chivalric heroes in the popular Tournament of Knights

Online audiences entertained by digital 2020 Ludlow Medieval Christmas Fayre

Audiences were treated to the authentic historic festivities of the annual Ludlow Medieval Christmas Fayre when it was held online for the first time.
Severn Valley Railway is launching something really exciting from Bridgnorth this Christmas

Christmas is coming to the Severn Valley Railway

The Severn Valley Railway launches its special Christmas services on Thursday 3rd December and is celebrating an enthusiastic take-up of seats on board its trains.
Judy Collins

Folk legend Judy Collins tops artist list for Shrewsbury Folk Festival 2021

Shrewsbury Folk Festival has made its first major line-up announcement for 2021 after managing to secure the majority of its performers from this year's festival that was postponed due to coronavirus.
Karen Lee of The Walnut

Wellington’s Walnut restaurant is on the move

An award-winning Wellington restaurant has announced exciting plans to move premises and diversify its offer.
quuens fish and chips frontage

New fish and chip shop opens in Shrewsbury

Shrewsbury has a sparkling new takeaway - Queens Fish & Chips is now open serving a delicious range of hot food.
The Vegan Hub Shrewsbury

Shrewsbury Vegan Hub goes online

Despite the latest lockdown one of Shrewsbury's newest Vegan outlets is continuing to trade with orders now being taken online.
- Advertisment -

Advertisement Feature

Weather

Shropshire
moderate rain
3.7 ° C
4 °
3.3 °
93 %
4.1kmh
90 %
Fri
5 °
Sat
5 °
Sun
4 °
Mon
4 °
Tue
5 °
- Advertisment -
- Advertisment -

Latest Articles

- Advertisment -