Telford private hire driver found guilty after failing to take a guide dog in his vehicle

A private hire driver has been found guilty of an offence under the Equality Act 2010 for refusing to take a blind man’s guide dog on a pre-booked journey.

During a trial at Telford Magistrates’ Court on Monday 5 November 2018, the Court heard that Mrs Bright booked a private hire car to collect her and her partner Mr Bowers – who is blind and uses a guide dog called ‘Isca’ – from Wellington train station on 4 January 2018 after they had travelled by train from the south west.

Mrs Bright gave evidence in court stating that she told the private hire company that she required a taxi for two adults, a guide dog and two large cases.

Mr Zaheer Mahmood, from Telford was dispatched to the train station, but upon seeing the guide dog, refused to take the fare saying “no dogs, no dogs”. As a result, Mrs Bright was forced to contact the operator and wait for a second car to be sent.

The incident was reported to Shropshire Council’s trading standards and licensing service, who investigated the matter and brought criminal proceedings against Mr Mahmood. Under the Equality Act 2010 it is an offence for the driver of a private hire vehicle to refuse to take an assistance dog.

Mr Mahmood pleaded not guilty, stating in his defence that he had purchased two part worn tyres earlier that day which were in the boot of his car – leaving no room for luggage. He claimed that he rang the operator and told them of the tyres being in his boot and requested a larger vehicle be sent to Mrs Bright.

During the investigation, officers obtained a recording of the phone call made by Mr Mahmood to his operator when he refused the job. In this call he stated: “You send me job in train station, and they go with a dog as well, you not tell me about dogs”.

At no time during the call did Mr Mahmood tell his operator that he had tyres in the boot, nor did he ask for a larger vehicle to be sent to carry out the booking.

Shropshire Council also obtained the booking records for all of Mr Mahmood’s journeys that day, which showed jobs at the hospital, supermarkets and train station. When questioned, Mr Mahmood claimed that none of his passengers that day required use of his car’s boot.

It was also identified during the course of the investigation that Mr Mahmood’s versions of events varied and appeared inconsistent. Having listened to all the evidence in the case, District Judge Jackson commented that he felt Mrs Bright had told the truth and he found it hard to believe that Mr Mahmood would have carried two car tyres in his boot for a full day.

Mr Mahmood was found guilty of the offence and sentenced to a fine of £300 as well as being ordered to pay a £30 victim surcharge and prosecution costs of £2,000.

Frances Darling, trading standards & licensing operations manager said:

“We welcome the outcome of this case. The law around taking assistance dogs is quite clear, whether they are guide dogs, hearing dogs or medical assistance dogs. It is a criminal offence for a private hire driver to refuse to take an assistance dog unless the driver has a medical exemption issued by the council’s licensing team. Shropshire Council takes incidents such as this extremely seriously as they affect some of the most vulnerable people in our society. Any future incidents of this kind will be investigated. Any private hire driver who refuses to take assistance dogs faces not only the prospect of legal action in the courts, but also being reported to the council’s licensing panel where there is a very strong likelihood that their private hire driver’s licence will be revoked.”

Joyce Barrow, Shropshire Council’s Cabinet member responsible for regulatory services said:

“It is incredibly disheartening to hear of this particular incident and that a driver licensed by Shropshire Council has clearly fallen far below what is expected of him. It is, however, reassuring that following an investigation and the legal process being followed, the Court has rightly found Zaheer Mahmood guilty. We will continue to ensure that taxi and private hire operators and drivers licensed by Shropshire Council comply with all legislation applicable to them. I encourage members of the public to report any suspected illegal activity to us.”

Supporting Shropshire Live...
Shropshire Live
Shropshire Live has been providing Shropshire with independent news and entertainment since 2009. Send us your news to interact@shropshirelive.com or call 01743 818 095. For advertising information call Fiona on 01743 816 817.
- Advertisement -

Featured Articles

The Clive Arms

Farm to Fork Dining at its Best: The Clive Arms

The Clive Arms, just outside of Ludlow and part of the Earl of Plymouth's Oakly Estate has reopened following an extensive refurbishment, with a range of great new menus focusing on fresh and seasonal produce.
Visitors to Shrewsbury Food Festival will be able to watch demonstrations from food bloggers, top Michelin starred chefs and industry experts

Shrewsbury Food Festival returns for its seventh year

Shrewsbury Food Festival returns on the 29th and 30th June with 200 exhibitors, a bigger, better BBQ area, demonstrations, chef school, live music and lots of fun activities for kids.
Holding baby hand - Generic

Families affected by a birth injury suffer for life says a leading lawyer

Physical and psychological effects are lifelong and impact every area of a family’s life according to a birth injuries specialist.
Leg Street in Oswestry will be closed along with Beatrice Street during the works. Image: Google Street View

Electricity cable upgrade work to begin in Oswestry

Leg Street and Beatrice Street in Oswestry will be closed from today until 5 July for electricity cable upgrade work to take place.

Ludlow man charged with GBH

A Ludlow man has been charged with GBH following a serious assault which took place in the town on Saturday.
Floats were decorated with various themes in this year's parade. Photo: Steven Oliver Photography

Thousands turn out for annual Shrewsbury Carnival & Show

Organisers of this year’s Shrewsbury Carnival & Show are celebrating another successful year with thousands of people attending the annual event.

Karol Jets is first signing for Telford Tigers 2 ahead of new season

Following the recent appointment of Dave Fielder as Telford Tigers 2 coach, the club has announced its first signing of the fast-approaching season.
SLCGA President Olive Brown, Winners - Rose Morgan & Hazel Hemsley and Ladies Captain Joy Foster. Photo: Mike Purnell

SLCGA Ladies 4BBB Pairs Open at Bridgnorth

Bridgnorth Golf Club were pleased to host the Shropshire Ladies County Golf Associations (SLCGA) Ladies 4BBB Pairs Open competition recently.
Rob Smith takes to a rather wet track at Croft. Photo: DSdigital/Dickon Siddall

Telford’s Smith battles hard on challenging rain-hit weekend

Excelr8 Motorsport driver Rob Smith added three more Independents Trophy points finishes to his tally at Croft Circuit in North Yorkshire on Sunday.
- Advertisement -
Thousands of people will attend this year's Shrewsbury Food Festival

Law firm helps to cook up a storm at food festival

A Shropshire law firm will be helping to cook up a storm when Shrewsbury Food Festival returns later this month.
Ashley Gamble took home the top accolade in the national Salon Business Awards

Shifnal salon wins national hair award

Local hair salon Ashley Gamble in Shifnal took home the top accolade in the national Salon Business Awards, beating thousands of hair salons from across the UK.
Darren Lloyd (centre) with Salop Leisure colleagues Ed Glover (left) and Chris Skitt who are taking on a 24-hour duathlon to raise money for him and his family to achieve bucket list wishes

Workmates aiming to make Darren’s bucket list wishes come true

Workmates at a Shropshire leisure company are banding together to raise money for a popular colleague who is bravely fighting terminal cancer.
FSC Chairman Professor Desmond Thompson is awarded The CIEEM Medal for his outstanding and life-long contribution to nature conservation and upland ecology

FSC chairman awarded top environmental accolade

The chairman of one of the UK’s leading environmental education charities is to be added to an A-list of highly influential ecologists.
Author Dave Courteen with a copy of More To Gain Than Just The Game at The Shrewsbury Club

Tennis stories the inspiration for stylish new book

A new book which combines inspirational first-hand tennis accounts with stunning photography is published this week.
Simon Macdonald, left, and Tom Meehan are the organisers of Shropshire FitFest 2019 at Shrewsbury’s London Road Sports Centre

Shropshire’s first dedicated fitness festival taking place in Shrewsbury next month

Shropshire’s first ever dedicated fitness spectacular, offering an all-day extravaganza of more than 60 classes, workshops and demonstrations, will launch next month.
- Advertisement -
Telford's Got Talent

Telford’s Got Talent final this weekend

The Telford’s Got Talent finals take place this weekend with thirteen acts battling it out this weekend to be crowned Telford’s Got Talent Winner 2019.
One of the Shire Horses at the event will be the Duchess

Shire horses from bygone era will be on display at Shropshire Vintage Show

The final preparations are taking place ahead of the 32nd annual Shropshire Vintage Show next month and some of ‘vintage vehicles’ on display will include 10 ‘heavy’ horses.
Children from Lawley Primary School in Telford get into the 'circus spirit' before the professionals arrive to perform on Sunday

Circus comes to Telford school for Father’s Day celebration

A professional circus is coming to town on Father’s Day to raise funds for a Telford school.
The Clive Arms

Farm to Fork Dining at its Best: The Clive Arms

The Clive Arms, just outside of Ludlow and part of the Earl of Plymouth's Oakly Estate has reopened following an extensive refurbishment, with a range of great new menus focusing on fresh and seasonal produce.
Visitors to Shrewsbury Food Festival will be able to watch demonstrations from food bloggers, top Michelin starred chefs and industry experts

Shrewsbury Food Festival returns for its seventh year

Shrewsbury Food Festival returns on the 29th and 30th June with 200 exhibitors, a bigger, better BBQ area, demonstrations, chef school, live music and lots of fun activities for kids.
Jason Bradley, the owner of Bradley’s Butchers & Delicatessen, with, left, Helen Bourne, property manager for TSR, and Amie Barter, agency surveyor for TSR, who handled the letting of the premises

New butchers and delicatessen opens in Shrewsbury

A new butchers and delicatessen has opened its doors in Shrewsbury. next to the town’s busy Column roundabout.
- Advertisment -

Featured Articles

Weather

Shropshire
overcast clouds
11 ° C
12.8 °
9.4 °
93 %
0.5kmh
100 %
Tue
18 °
Wed
15 °
Thu
16 °
Fri
15 °
Sat
15 °
- Advertisment -
- Advertisment -

Latest Articles

- Advertisment -