Telford private hire driver found guilty after failing to take a guide dog in his vehicle

A private hire driver has been found guilty of an offence under the Equality Act 2010 for refusing to take a blind man’s guide dog on a pre-booked journey.

During a trial at Telford Magistrates’ Court on Monday 5 November 2018, the Court heard that Mrs Bright booked a private hire car to collect her and her partner Mr Bowers – who is blind and uses a guide dog called ‘Isca’ – from Wellington train station on 4 January 2018 after they had travelled by train from the south west.

Mrs Bright gave evidence in court stating that she told the private hire company that she required a taxi for two adults, a guide dog and two large cases.

Mr Zaheer Mahmood, from Telford was dispatched to the train station, but upon seeing the guide dog, refused to take the fare saying “no dogs, no dogs”. As a result, Mrs Bright was forced to contact the operator and wait for a second car to be sent.

The incident was reported to Shropshire Council’s trading standards and licensing service, who investigated the matter and brought criminal proceedings against Mr Mahmood. Under the Equality Act 2010 it is an offence for the driver of a private hire vehicle to refuse to take an assistance dog.

Mr Mahmood pleaded not guilty, stating in his defence that he had purchased two part worn tyres earlier that day which were in the boot of his car – leaving no room for luggage. He claimed that he rang the operator and told them of the tyres being in his boot and requested a larger vehicle be sent to Mrs Bright.

During the investigation, officers obtained a recording of the phone call made by Mr Mahmood to his operator when he refused the job. In this call he stated: “You send me job in train station, and they go with a dog as well, you not tell me about dogs”.

At no time during the call did Mr Mahmood tell his operator that he had tyres in the boot, nor did he ask for a larger vehicle to be sent to carry out the booking.

Shropshire Council also obtained the booking records for all of Mr Mahmood’s journeys that day, which showed jobs at the hospital, supermarkets and train station. When questioned, Mr Mahmood claimed that none of his passengers that day required use of his car’s boot.

It was also identified during the course of the investigation that Mr Mahmood’s versions of events varied and appeared inconsistent. Having listened to all the evidence in the case, District Judge Jackson commented that he felt Mrs Bright had told the truth and he found it hard to believe that Mr Mahmood would have carried two car tyres in his boot for a full day.

Mr Mahmood was found guilty of the offence and sentenced to a fine of £300 as well as being ordered to pay a £30 victim surcharge and prosecution costs of £2,000.

Frances Darling, trading standards & licensing operations manager said:

“We welcome the outcome of this case. The law around taking assistance dogs is quite clear, whether they are guide dogs, hearing dogs or medical assistance dogs. It is a criminal offence for a private hire driver to refuse to take an assistance dog unless the driver has a medical exemption issued by the council’s licensing team. Shropshire Council takes incidents such as this extremely seriously as they affect some of the most vulnerable people in our society. Any future incidents of this kind will be investigated. Any private hire driver who refuses to take assistance dogs faces not only the prospect of legal action in the courts, but also being reported to the council’s licensing panel where there is a very strong likelihood that their private hire driver’s licence will be revoked.”

Joyce Barrow, Shropshire Council’s Cabinet member responsible for regulatory services said:

“It is incredibly disheartening to hear of this particular incident and that a driver licensed by Shropshire Council has clearly fallen far below what is expected of him. It is, however, reassuring that following an investigation and the legal process being followed, the Court has rightly found Zaheer Mahmood guilty. We will continue to ensure that taxi and private hire operators and drivers licensed by Shropshire Council comply with all legislation applicable to them. I encourage members of the public to report any suspected illegal activity to us.”

Supporting Shropshire Live...
Shropshire Live
Shropshire Live has been providing Shropshire with independent news and entertainment since 2009. Send us your news to interact@shropshirelive.com or call 01743 818 095. For advertising information call Fiona on 01743 816 817.

Featured Articles

Easter Featured Article

Out and About in Shropshire Easter 2019

It is busy time across Shropshire this Easter with plenty of events and activities across the county. Take a look at some of the events near you.

Make Mum’s Day with a little helping hand from Shrewsbury Shopping

This Mother’s Day, Shrewsbury Shopping are showing their appreciation for Shropshire Mums, with lots of free fun and a little free gift in the approach to Mother’s Day.
- Advertisement -

Request to review Future Fit plans passed to Independent Reconfiguration Panel

Health Secretary Rt Hon Matt Hancock MP has passed Telford & Wrekin Council’s request to review Future Fit’s decision on to the next stage of the referral process.

Woman has bag snatched whilst walking in Telford Town Park

A woman had her handbag snatched from her whilst walking in Telford Town Park yesterday.

£100,000 Legacy Funding will help provide transitional housing for young people in Wellington

Telford & Wrekin Council is to make a grant of £100,000 available to YMCA Wellington to support the development of 13 units of affordable transitional housing for young people.

Match Preview: Shrewsbury Town v Portsmouth

Shrewsbury Town has a defensive crisis on their hands as they prepare to face promotion contenders Portsmouth.
Harriet Otter and Annie

Ellesmere’s equestrian team show excellence at competition

The equestrian team at Ellesmere College are jumping for joy after a student won her class at a high profile qualifying competition.
Josh Andrady

Shropshire school pupil bats his way to tour of India

A Shropshire pupil is continuing to bowl over cricketing experts with his talents - as he was selected to tour India as part of an academy programme.
- Advertisement -
Morris & Company Family Board

Family business wins Regional Award in anniversary year

Morris & Company is celebrating after becoming the first winner of the ‘Family Business of the Year’ accolade in the 2019 West Midlands Business Masters Awards.
Carl Phillips (Telford & Wrekin Council) with Andy Wheeler (TTC Group)

TTC Group wins Telford & Wrekin Council contract to improve safety of local taxi drivers

TTC Group has won a contract with Telford & Wrekin Council to improve the performance and safety of local taxi and private hire drivers.
Kay Kelly, training partner with Lanyon Bowdler

Shropshire law firm in the running to win third national award in a row

A Shropshire law firm is in the running to win a third national award in a row at a special ceremony to be held in London later this year.
Mark Allsop, Managing Director of Yarrington and Andrew Cross, Chairman of Shropshire Horticultural Society

New app launched for Shrewsbury Flower Show

A new app is to make it easier for visitors to plan and enjoy their day at this year's Shrewsbury Flower Show.
Maggie Kennerley, a Transformation Midwife from Shropshire, who is taking part in the Velo Birmingham & Midlands to raise money for Cure Leukaemia

Baschurch Rollers cycling for Cure Leukaemia at Velo

A health professional from Shropshire will be marking International Nurses Day by cycling 100 miles for Cure Leukaemia.
Art Historian, Sarah Gathercole, Qube Arts Officer, Charlotte Jackson, Volunteer, Jan Hedger and Qube Arts Development Officer, Vanessa Baldry

Volunteer’s exhibition honours Oswestry’s Homefront Heroines

A multimedia exhibition celebrating the role of local women during the First World War opens on March 14 at Qube Gallery in Oswestry.
- Advertisement -
Shropshire County Show 2019 Rev

Shropshire County Show set for a spectacular year

The Shropshire County Show is back for 2019 and this year is set to be bigger and better than ever before.
Easter Featured Article

Out and About in Shropshire Easter 2019

It is busy time across Shropshire this Easter with plenty of events and activities across the county. Take a look at some of the events near you.
The Big Busk’s popular, free “try-it-out” music room will be run by Music Heroes

Be a music hero at The Big Busk

The Big Busk’s popular, free “try-it-out” music room will be back when Shrewsbury’s street music festival returns on 6 April.

Shrewsbury in top spot for food hygiene ratings in the West Midlands

Shrewsbury has come top for food hygiene ratings in the West Midlands, according to a new report.

Special Easter events at Shrewsbury’s award-winning Market Hall

Events at Shrewsbury’s award-winning Market Hall kick off on Saturday, April 6 when its doors open for the first of its 2019 line-up of popular late night events.
Whitchurch Food and Drink Festival takes place in April

Festival team to help boost Whitchurch Food and Drink event

Shropshire Festivals is to play a major role in this year’s Whitchurch Food and Drink Festival, organisers have revealed.

Featured Articles

- Advertisment -

Weather

Shropshire
scattered clouds
8.2 ° C
9.4 °
6.7 °
65 %
4.6kmh
40 %
Sat
10 °
Sun
10 °
Mon
11 °
Tue
12 °
Wed
12 °
- Advertisment -
- Advertisment -

Latest Articles

- Advertisment -