MoD payout after asbestos death is linked to Donnington Army Base fire

A family whose mum died of cancer caused by asbestos exposure have been awarded a ‘substantial’ payout from the Ministry of Defence.

Susan Maughan pictured with two of her daughters inhaled asbestos dust following a fire at COD Donnington in 1983
Susan Maughan pictured with two of her daughters inhaled asbestos dust following a fire at COD Donnington in 1983

Susan Maughan inhaled the toxic dust following a fire at army depot COD Donnington in 1983, which scattered ash containing asbestos for miles in the streets around her Telford home.

It was three days before the council began its clean-up operation, by which time many residents, like Susan, had already done so themselves.

Tragically for the house-proud mum, her exposure was enough to cause mesothelioma – an aggressive and incurable cancer, typically found in the lungs, which can lie dormant for decades before symptoms appear.

Susan, a mum-of-four who also had eight grandchildren and one great-grandchild, died in 2015 aged 63, three years after her diagnosis.

Now, following legal action, the Ministry of Defence, which owned the army base, has reached a ‘substantial’ out-of-court settlement with the family.

But daughters Sonia, Cath and Lorraine, who rallied round to care for their mum when she fell ill, fear they too could be living with the same death sentence.

Lorraine, 47, who was just 11 at the time, said: “Sadly I don’t think mum will be the last victim. My sisters and I now also worry for our health as we played with the dust and debris, which looked like snow, as did many other children.

“We discussed legal action when mum was alive and I’m glad we’ve been able to get justice for her, but it doesn’t undo what’s happened. We all miss her so much.

“You never know what’s around the corner, but it’s hard when someone gets taken away because of a substance that shouldn’t have been used in the first place and in such a devastating way.

“Mum was a fighter, but there was nothing the doctors could do. She was on oxygen all the time and wouldn’t leave the house. We just watched her get weaker and weaker.”

Susan, who also had a son Allan, was living in Winsford, Cheshire, at the time of her death. Over the years she held various jobs including as a cleaner and a hairdresser, but an inquest into her death ruled she had ‘almost certainly’ been exposed to asbestos in the aftermath of the warehouse blaze.

Madelene Holdsworth, head of the industrial disease department at law firm Slater and Gordon, represented the family and is also handling several other cases connected to the fire.

She added: “The ash was spread across a 15-square mile area, much of it residential, so it is likely that hundreds, if not thousands, of people were exposed to asbestos that day.

“By 1983 the dangers were known and while the fire itself was not intentional, what we do know is that the Ministry of Defence had been warned about the lack of fire protection measures and that the building itself was a fire hazard.

“On behalf of the family, I would like to thank the many people who lived in the area at that time and came forward after reading Susan’s story to share their memories with us.

“Nothing will bring her back, but I am pleased that we have at least been able to give her family the answers as to why her life was so tragically and cruelly cut short.”

Supporting Shropshire Live...
Shropshire Live
Shropshire Live has been providing Shropshire with independent news and entertainment since 2009. Send us your news to or call 01743 818 095. For advertising information call Fiona on 01743 816 817.
- Advertising -

Featured Articles

aico new build

Aico Open Day to welcome local community and employees

Aico, the Market Leader in domestic Smoke and Carbon Monoxide Alarms, will be relocating in October 2019 to a brand-new purpose-built three storey building in Oswestry.
Summer in Shropshire

Things to do this Summer in Shropshire

There is so much going on across Shropshire this Summer, here are some events and things to do to get you out and about across our county.
Students collect their GCSE results at Sir John Talbot’s School in Whitchurch

GCSE Results 2019: Shropshire roundup

Students are today collecting their GCSE results with an estimated 5.2 million GCSE entries this summer – up 50,000 on the previous year.

West Midlands Ambulance Service rated ‘Outstanding’ by CQC

The Care Quality Commission has rated West Midlands Ambulance Service as ‘Outstanding’ following its latest inspection.

Severn Hospice ‘Passes GO’ following Shrewsbury MONOPOLY public vote

Shrewsbury MONOPOLY players will soon be able to roll their dice and land on Severn Hospice.
Wicketkeeper Matt Swift hit an unbeaten 92 for Shropshire in the first innings

Shropshire’s cricketers beaten heavily by Cheshire in the Unicorns Championship

Three challenging days at Nantwich ended with Shropshire’s cricketers losing heavily to Cheshire in the Unicorns Championship.
Clive Knight received his LTA Meritorious Service Award from Cathie Sabin, Shropshire’s former LTA president

Prestigious LTA award for Shropshire’s Clive Knight

Shropshire’s Clive Knight has received a prestigious award from the Lawn Tennis Association.

Match Report: Accrington Stanley 2 – 3 Shrewsbury Town

Daniel Udoh is the man of the moment as the debutant helps Shrewsbury Town to complete a remarkable turnaround.
- Advertising -
Simon Davies from Flex IT with Carolyn Freeman, business manager of Wace Morgan and Diana Packwood, managing partner Wace Morgan

Legal firm’s £100,000 investment in new IT systems

A Shropshire law firm has announced a major £100,000 investment in order to ‘future proof’ the firm.
Accountants Dave Leddington, Rob Chadderton and Alex Stone

Shropshire accountants raise a toast to Thirsty Thursdays

An accountancy firm based in Telford has launched a new networking evening with a twist – Thirsty Thursdays.
Madelaine Reed, Liz Lowe and Nicola Matthews at Abbey Lawn, Shrewsbury

Consultancy finds new home at Shrewsbury business park

A specialist engineering consultancy serving clients mainly overseas looked closer to home for its new base in Shrewsbury.
Zoe Watson of Alderford Lake and Megan Potter from the Hope House fundraising team get ready for the race

Alderford Lake to go quackers for local children’s hospice

Hope House Children’s Hospices are holding a Duck Race at Alderford Lake on Sunday 8 September at 1pm raising funds for the local charity.
Lois Harding and Kathryn Holmes ask creatives to be inspired by their local area for The Wrekin Housing Group’s next calendar

Artists compete in 2020 calendar competition

The countdown is on for creative types to enter their work in a competition, which could see them featured in a popular calendar.
Horatio’s Garden Oswestry was created by acclaimed garden designer and Gardeners’ Question Time panellist, Bunny Guinness. Photo: Mandy Jones

Horatio’s Garden Oswestry seeks volunteers

UK charity Horatio’s Garden are looking for volunteers to join their new, friendly team at their recently opened Oswestry garden.
- Advertising -

Free Mini exhibition drives into Shrewsbury prison

Mini is 60 and to mark the occasion The West Midlands Mini Owners Group are celebrating behind the high walls of Shrewsbury Prison this Bank Holiday weekend.
Georgie Dixon, marketing and event coordinator at sponsors Rybrook Shrewsbury with Hannah Gamston, event manager at Severn Hospice

Severn Hospice revs up support for outdoor cinema

A Shropshire car dealership is revving up support for a local charity by backing its upcoming outdoor cinema screening events.
David Domoney from ITV’s Love Your Garden is appearing at this year's show

Final preparations take place ahead of Shrewsbury Flower Show

Organisers of this year’s Shrewsbury Flower Show are putting the final touches to The Quarry ahead of what promises to be another bumper event.
Charlotte Nutting & Alex Nicoll at The Meadow Inn

Popular Ironbridge pub looks forward to new future

A popular Ironbridge pub has been given a promising new lease of life having been acquired by the same successful team behind the nearby White Hart.

Ludlow Farmshop celebrates Great Taste Award success

Ludlow Farmshop is celebrating after being awarded a number of Great Taste awards.
Publican Lance Pettet outside The Lamb Inn

£285,000 investment breathes new life into The Lamb Inn, Edgmond

The Lamb Inn, situated in the village of Edgmond near Newport has reopened following a £285,000 investment.
- Advertisment -

Featured Articles


shower rain
19.2 ° C
20.6 °
17.8 °
77 %
75 %
21 °
20 °
23 °
25 °
24 °
- Advertisment -
- Advertisment -

Latest Articles

- Advertisment -