Job retention scheme a “game changer”, says legal expert

This article is more than 8 months old. Please read this page keeping its age in mind.

Employment law experts have welcomed the latest government measures to pay up to 80 per cent of employees’ wages – describing them as a “game changer”.

John Merry, head of employment at Lanyon Bowdler
John Merry, head of employment at Lanyon Bowdler

The Chancellor has announced a package of temporary measures to support people and businesses in the wake of disruption caused by the Covid-19 outbreak.

This included reference to a Coronavirus Job Retention Scheme which, in basic terms, will cover 80 per cent of payments to employees up to a total of £2,500 per month, back-dated to 1 March – initially for three months, but to be extended “if necessary”.

John Merry, head of employment at Shropshire law firm Lanyon Bowdler, said “As the name suggests, the scheme is aimed at minimising job losses. Whilst full details are awaited, what is clear is that this will be a game changer for many businesses and their employees.

“It might not only prevent future dismissals, but some employers might look to withdraw notices of dismissal that have already been given, or re-engage employees who have already been dismissed.”

The government has stated that all UK employers will be able to access support to continue paying part of the salary for employees who are “furloughed”, and has also described the support as applying to employees who are “otherwise laid off”.

John explained: “The word ‘furlough’ means to allow or force someone to be absent temporarily from work. Colloquially, ‘laid off’ can be taken to mean ‘dismissed’, but in the usual legal sense it means being temporarily required to not work.

“Despite the inconsistency in the terms used by the government, and how they have been used, it’s clear that the scheme is intended to apply to individuals who remain employed but are temporarily not required to work.”

Initial guidance states that to access the scheme, employers will need to designate affected employees as ‘furloughed workers’, notify them of this change, and submit information to HMRC through an online portal, which is intended to be operating by the end of April.

John added: “Within guidance published online, there is a hint that businesses will be able to reclaim 80 per cent of all costs in relation to employees, and not just wages, up to the monthly cap of £2,500, such as in relation to national insurance and pension contributions, medical or life insurance and company cars – but whether this is to be so remains to be seen.

“Also, as yet, there’s no indication as to how the level of pay is to be determined under the scheme for employees with irregular earnings, such as those who work different hours each week.”

The government has said that employers can top up laid off employees’ pay to full pay, but they do not have to. However, the more pertinent point is whether it is open to employers to not pay employees in full.

John said: “The scheme will not provide employers with the automatic right to lay employees off on reduced pay. To do this, there must either be a contractual provision entitling the employer to do so, or else employee consent will be required.

“The reality is that, surely, where employers don’t have a contractual right to lay employees off, most employees will gratefully accept being laid off on 80 per cent of full pay rather than face possible dismissal. But some might not.

“In that event, employers can look to dismiss by reason of redundancy – although a fair procedure must be followed in the case of employees with two or more years’ service, and collective consultation rules can apply where 20 or more employees are affected.”

John said as positive a move as the new scheme was for protecting employees, it might cause some resentment.

He added: “If some employees have to continue working to earn their pay whilst others are getting most of their pay for doing nothing, this might impact on employment relations.

“To address this, some employers who are to furlough only a proportion of their workforce might look to rotate the affected employees to share the ‘benefit’ of being laid off.

“There is no suggestion so far that the scheme will assist businesses or employees in the context of short-time working, that is to say, when an employee’s working hours are temporarily reduced.

“For example, some employees will have had, or will have, their working week reduced, maybe from five days to four, or even down to one. It seems that as such employees are not completely laid off, the government will not provide funds for employers to top their pay up to any extent.

“Again, this might cause employees to feel resentment – particularly if they have colleagues who are laid off altogether on 80 per cent of full pay.

“Employers might therefore want to revise arrangements for short-time working in light of the availability of the Job Retention Scheme. “It remains to be seen, but it might be possible to alternate employees between periods of lay-off and periods of work, and/or to rotate employees who are laid off, to maximise the funding accessible from the scheme and also spread around the workforce the impact of  20 per cent reductions in pay.”

Shropshire Business News sponsored by...
Shropshire Live Business
The latest Shropshire business news from the Shropshire Live team. Send us your business news to Interested in advertising with us from just £50 per week? Call Fiona on 01743 816 817 or email
Advertise with us for £50 per week

Advertisement Feature

Simply Ribbons is not what you would expect in more ways than one!

Catering for individuals, small businesses and multinationals Simply Ribbons offer high-quality ribbons from UK and European manufacturers.
Telford College - Employer incentives 1

Telford College offers cash incentives to local employers

Telford College is offering Government-funded cash incentives to Shropshire employers, to give young people a helping hand with their careers.
- Advertising -
Advertise with Shropshire Live for £50 per week

Two arrested in connection with county lines drug dealing

Two people have been arrested in connection with county lines drug dealing in Shropshire.

Overwhelming support for reducing traffic in Shrewsbury town centre, says survey

There is overwhelming support for reducing the number of vehicles driving through the centre of Shrewsbury, according to a survey.
Coleham Primary School in Shrewsbury. Photo: Shropshire Council

School Street initiative launches outside Shrewsbury primary school

A Shrewsbury street has today become the first ‘School Street’ in the county, enabling children to be dropped off and picked up in a safe and socially-distanced way.

FA Cup Round 2 Match Report: Shrewsbury Town 1 – 0 Oxford City (AET)

Shrewsbury Town required extra time to edge past non-league Oxford City as Steve Cotterill takes charge for the first time.

FA Cup Round 2 Match Preview: Shrewsbury Town V Oxford City

The post Sam Ricketts era at Shrewsbury Town begins with a second round FA Cup tie against non-league Oxford City.

Shrewsbury Town appoint Steve Cotterill as manager

Shrewsbury Town has moved swiftly to appoint vastly experienced Steve Cotterill on a three-and-a-half-year deal.
- Advertising -
Hanna Sebright with critical care paramedic Ryan Ferris at the Midlands Air Ambulance Charity headquarters

Shropshire Chamber welcomes Midlands Air Ambulance Charity as Corporate member

Midlands Air Ambulance Charity, which has an operational base at RAF Cosford, is the latest organisation to become a Corporate member of Shropshire Chamber of Commerce.
Claire Flavell, Director of Care at Bluebird Care Shropshire

Bluebird Care’s Claire Flavell reaches finals of Covid Heroes Awards

Claire Flavell, the Director of Care at Bluebird Care Shropshire, has reached the final of the Bluebird Care Covid Heroes Awards.
Carl Jones and Chris Pritchard welcome viewers to the latest show

Shropshire Business Live TV returns for its latest show

Shropshire Business Live TV, a collaboration between three local media organisations, returned on Thursday 26 November with a brand new live show.
The lights and music will be on daily from 4:30pm through to 10pm

Charity Christmas lights shine bright in Higher Heath

For the third year running, a house in Twemlows Avenue, Higher Heath, Whitchurch will be decked with lights in aid of the Midlands Air Ambulance Charity (MAAC).
Denise Kerr

Oswestry nursery manager launches debut children’s book

A manager from a local Oswestry Nursery, Jeanette Pearson-Tanner, has launched her debut children’s book – ‘The Pre School Detectives’.
Year 5 have made an early bid in the hope of becoming the next ‘Reading Champions!

Readers reap the rewards at Ellesmere Primary School

Bookworms at Ellesmere Primary School have caught the reading bug with the launch of a new initiative to get them excited about literature.
- Advertising -
Ludlow’s annual Medieval Christmas Fayre - Knight

Stage is set to enjoy online 2020 Ludlow Medieval Christmas Fayre

Final preparations are being made before the annual Ludlow Medieval Christmas Fayre gets under way online this weekend.
Fundraiser Nic Sciarillo from Hope House in Oswestry

A great Christmas night out bought indoors by Hope House Children’s Hospices

While the traditional Christmas night out is probably off the table this year, Hope House Children’s Hospices will be bringing the big night out, in this December.
Keith Lemon and Richard Blackwood at Blists Hill - Image ITV

Keith Lemon and Richard Blackwood get into the swing of things at Blists Hill

Blists Hill Victorian Town has been visited by television celebrities Keith Lemon and Richard Blackwood to film ITV show Shopping with Keith Lemon.
Karen Lee of The Walnut

Wellington’s Walnut restaurant is on the move

An award-winning Wellington restaurant has announced exciting plans to move premises and diversify its offer.
quuens fish and chips frontage

New fish and chip shop opens in Shrewsbury

Shrewsbury has a sparkling new takeaway - Queens Fish & Chips is now open serving a delicious range of hot food.
The Vegan Hub Shrewsbury

Shrewsbury Vegan Hub goes online

Despite the latest lockdown one of Shrewsbury's newest Vegan outlets is continuing to trade with orders now being taken online.
- Advertisment -

Advertisement Feature


overcast clouds
5.5 ° C
6.1 °
4.4 °
81 %
100 %
6 °
8 °
5 °
3 °
3 °
- Advertisment -
- Advertisment -

Latest Articles

- Advertisment -